Current:Home > MarketsNew EPA Rule Change Saves Industry Money but Exacts a Climate Cost -Stellar Financial Insights
New EPA Rule Change Saves Industry Money but Exacts a Climate Cost
View
Date:2025-04-15 15:04:54
For the latest Trump Administration rollback of Environmental Protection Agency rules, the math goes something like this: The change will save businesses and industries $24 million a year. Earth’s atmosphere, on the other hand, will receive emissions of pollutants equivalent to at least 625,000 new cars being added to the road.
This week, EPA Administrator Andrew R. Wheeler signed a new rule that relaxes the requirements that owners and operators of refrigeration equipment have leak detection and maintenance programs for hydrofluorocarbons, a set of refrigerants often referred to as “climate super-pollutants.”
The rule change—the latest reversal of an Obama-era regulation—was part of the administration’s agenda to ease burdens on industry.
“We just think it’s a baffling and wrong-headed move,” said David Doniger, a senior strategic director with the Natural Resources Defense Council, which opposed the rollback. “Considering there are thousands of facilities subject to these rules, [$24 million] is pocket change savings.”
The rule applies to a large segment of the nation’s commercial sector, from agriculture and crop production to the manufacturing of food and beverage products, petrochemicals, plastics, electronics, medical equipment and even the operation of ice skating rinks.
The NRDC said the agency used old data to underestimate the additional greenhouse gas emissions that would result from the rule change. In fact, Doniger said, the rule change will release into the atmosphere pollutants equivalent to the carbon dioxide emissions of 1 million cars.
An EPA spokeswoman defended Wheeler’s decision, saying that the agency determined that in 2016 it had exceeded its statutory authority by extending leak-detection and maintenance requirements to equipment using refrigerants like hydrofluorocarbons or HFCs.
HFCs replaced earlier refrigerants that severely damaged Earth’s protective ozone layer, and their use has been growing. In its new rule, the EPA echoed an industry assertion that the agency lacked the legal authority to retain the Obama-era requirements for HFCs.
One of the industry groups backing the Trump administration’s rule change is the National Environmental Development Association’s Clean Air Project, representing major companies such as Boeing, BP, Procter & Gamble, Lilly and Koch Industries. The law firm representing the association did not respond to a request by InsideClimate News for comment. But in written comments to the EPA, a lawyer representing the association called the Obama-era rule “arbitrary” and “punitive.”
HFCs are among a group of chemicals known as “short-lived climate pollutants,” which don’t last very long in the atmosphere compared to carbon dioxide, which in some cases can remain in circulation for thousands of years.
Once released into the atmosphere, however, HFCs remain for only about 15 to 30 years, and their impact on global warming can be hundreds to thousands of times greater than that of carbon dioxide, according to the Climate and Clean Air Coalition, a global partnership working to curb short-lived climate pollutants.
Fifteen states and Washington, D.C., tried to persuade the EPA to retain the Obama administration’s leak detection and maintenance rules for HFCs. Led by Massachusetts and California, they argued that the Clean Air Act gave the EPA broad authority to stop leaks from ozone-depleting chemicals and their replacements.
“Stratospheric ozone depletion and climate change are among the most severe environmental threats faced by modern human civilization,” the states argued. “The states strongly oppose any EPA action that unlawfully licenses industry to emit more ozone- and climate-damaging chemicals at the expense of human and environmental health and in contravention of the Clean Air Act and its core purposes.”
Last year an amendment to the Montreal Protocol—the 1987 treaty that put in check ozone-depleting chemicals—went into force, requiring the phase-out of HFCs by 2030. Ninety-three countries and the European Union have signed the treaty, although the Trump administration has not yet sent it to the Senate for ratification.
Congress is also weighing bipartisan legislation to phase out HFCs. In November, Sens. Tom Carper (D-Del.), and John Kennedy (R-La.) introduced the American Innovation and Manufacturing Act (AIM), a bill that would authorize a 15-year phasedown of HFCs and has 31 cosponsors, including both Republicans and Democrats.
Rep. Paul Tonko (D-N.Y.), has introduced a similar bill, with 21 co-sponsors, also including a mix of Republicans and Democrats.
Doniger said the strong bipartisan support to tackle HFCs is a sharp contrast to the EPA’s decision to relax the rule on leak detection and maintenance in refrigeration.
One provision of the bill, he said, “makes clear EPA has the authority to require refrigerant leak management.”
veryGood! (8815)
Related
- Chuck Scarborough signs off: Hoda Kotb, Al Roker tribute legendary New York anchor
- The semi driver rescued dangling from a bridge had been struck by an oncoming vehicle: mayor
- NPR puzzlemaster Will Shortz says he is recovering from a stroke
- Immigration ‘parole’ is a well-worn tool for US presidents. It faces a big test in 2024 elections
- Spooky or not? Some Choa Chu Kang residents say community garden resembles cemetery
- NFL draft's QB conundrum: Could any 2024 passers be better than Caleb Williams?
- Sam Smith Debuts Daring Look While Modeling at Paris Fashion Week
- Organization & Storage Solutions That Are So Much Better Than Shoving Everything In Your Entryway Closet
- Jamie Foxx gets stitches after a glass is thrown at him during dinner in Beverly Hills
- 2024 Masters Tournament: Who will participate at Augusta? How to watch, odds, TV schedule
Ranking
- Woman dies after Singapore family of 3 gets into accident in Taiwan
- Nikki Haley wins the District of Columbia’s Republican primary and gets her first 2024 victory
- You can get two free Krispy Kreme doughnuts on Super Tuesday. Here's what to know.
- 4 new astronauts head to the International Space Station for a 6-month stay
- House passes bill to add 66 new federal judgeships, but prospects murky after Biden veto threat
- Inside the story of the notorious Menendez brothers case
- Mi abuela es un meme y es un poco por mi culpa
- Two fragile DC neighborhoods hang in the balance as the Wizards and Capitals consider leaving town
Recommendation
Newly elected West Virginia lawmaker arrested and accused of making terroristic threats
Iris Apfel, fashion icon who garnered social media fame in her later years, dies at 102
16 Products That Will Help You Easily Tackle Your Mile-Long List of Chores While Making Them Fun
USWNT rebounds from humbling loss, defeats Colombia in Concacaf W Gold Cup quarterfinal
Romantasy reigns on spicy BookTok: Recommendations from the internet’s favorite genre
Texas WR Xavier Worthy breaks John Ross' NFL combine record with 4.21-second 40-yard dash
Trump escalates his immigration rhetoric with baseless claim about Biden trying to overthrow the US
Caitlin Clark breaks Pete Maravich's all-time scoring record as Iowa beats Ohio State